Best Window & Door Replacement Companies in New York
New York

Best Window & Door Replacement Companies in New York

Find trusted window & door replacement professionals serving New York. All contractors are independently researched and certified.

Only companies with a Certified Best Pick® badge meet our strict satisfaction & licensing requirements and are eligible for the Best Pick Guarantee.

6
Recommended Pros
4k+
Verified Reviews
Locally FocusedResearch-VerifiedFree Service

6 Contractors

Only companies with a Certified Best Pick® badge meet our strict satisfaction & licensing requirements and are eligible for the Best Pick Guarantee.

Power Home Remodeling
Certified Best Pick

Power Home Remodeling

Certified Pro

"For over 30 years, Power Home Remodeling has been the most trusted name in exterior remodeling: trusted because we care about our products being energy efficient and cost effective; trusted because we value integrity, honesty, and true craftsmanship; and trusted because we believe in total customer satisfaction."

3rd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp
Mr. Handyman Serving Huntington, Smithtown, and Islip
Certified Best Pick

Mr. Handyman Serving Huntington, Smithtown, and Islip

Certified Pro

"Discover the exceptional quality and reliability of Mr. Handyman, your locally owned and operated experts in home and business repairs and improvements. We're proud of our dedicated team, our reputation for excellence, and our commitment to top-notch service and craftsmanship, all backed by our one-year Done Right Promise."

3rd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp
EcoView Windows of Long Island
Certified Best Pick

EcoView Windows of Long Island

Certified Pro

"We specialize in energy-efficient windows, doors, siding, and roofing replacement. We pride ourselves on providing quality products, competitive pricing, professional installation, and lifetime warranties."

3rd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp
PJ Fitzpatrick, LLC
Certified Best Pick

PJ Fitzpatrick, LLC

Certified Pro

"As one of the most trusted names in home improvement, PJ Fitzpatrick has been providing quality service to homeowners since 1980. Our goal is to leave our customers 100 percent satisfied and to provide the best in siding, roofing, doors, windows, baths, gutters, insulation, and more."

2nd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp
Renewal by Andersen
Certified Best Pick

Renewal by Andersen

Certified Pro

"Renewal by Andersen is the premier window replacement division of Andersen Windows, a company with over 120 years of innovation in crafting high-quality windows. With our customer-centered experience and our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, we stand by our work now and for years to come."

2nd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp
Five Star Improvements, Inc
Certified Best Pick

Five Star Improvements, Inc

Certified Pro

"Five Star Improvements, Inc is a local, full-service home remodeling company offering top-notch products. We're proud to build relationships with our customers and take the time to fully understand their expectations. Our business is built on a foundation of honesty, transparency, and open communication."

1st year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp

Recent Project Requests in New York

Real homeowners looking for window & door replacement in your area

Monroe

"Front door need to be replaced and Need to fix the sliding door. Replace the door panel, lock and ne..."

May 16, 2026
West Islip

"I would like to have a window replacement installed. I already have the new window ready to go."

Sep 22, 2025
Melville

"New screen sliding door needs to be installed"

Jul 1, 2025
Brentwood

"We are looking to get replacement screen for multiple windows. Do you give quotes for pricing?"

Apr 9, 2025
Floral Park

"Windows and front door"

Mar 25, 2025
Certification Standards

How New York Window & Door Replacement Companies Earn Best Pick Certification

Only window & door replacement companies that meet our strict standards earn Best Pick status.

Customer Satisfaction

Window & Door Replacement companies must maintain a 4.0+ rating and an 80% recommendation rate.

Licensing & Insurance

Current state contractor license verification and general liability insurance for window & door replacement work

Business Stability

Minimum 1 year in business with established local presence

Verified State Standing

Maintain active business registration and in good standing with the state

Operational Excellence

Consistent window & door replacement service quality across all projects

Annual Re-Certification

Must re-qualify every year through new research

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Certified Best Pick® window & door replacement companies in New York

  • Drafts whistling through wood windows in historic Brooklyn brownstones or upstate Buffalo neighborhoods often point to decayed single-pane wood sash. These gaps force your heating system to work overtime during severe lake-effect snows since the old frames lack modern energy-efficient glazing.
  • Foggy glass between the panes (the seal on the double-pane window has failed — common on windows installed in the late 1980s to mid 1990s) is a clear sign your window is no longer insulating. In Albany and the Hudson Valley, our dramatic seasonal temperature swings wear out the seals around the edges of these older vinyl frames.
  • Dark water staining or soft wood along your lower window sills usually indicates that moisture is getting trapped inside the frame. For mid-century homes built with metal frames that conduct heat or cold straight through (a 'thermal bridge'), winter condensation will run down and rot the surrounding wall trim.

If you notice any of these signs, document the damage with physical photos from the ground and reach out to a professional who understands New York's complex regional climate rules.

  1. Read the label of your window from the inside to find the cold-climate energy rating (ENERGY STAR Northern V7.0, U-factor 0.22 or lower) if you live in upstate metros like Syracuse. For downstate counties like Nassau, look for a U-factor of 0.25 or lower instead, which matches our slightly milder regional climate.
  2. Press the lower wooden corners of your exterior window frames and sill plates from the ground with a flat screwdriver to test for active decay. In our humid New York summers and snowy winters, wood rot can quietly destroy older structural framing before the damage becomes obvious on the surface.
  3. Check the operation of any bedroom windows to ensure they can easily open from the inside without requiring any tools. Under domestic safety codes, bedroom windows must provide a clear exit path, which is a common failure point for older double-hung wood frames that bind from seasonal humidity.
  • WHEN TO STOP AND CALL A PRO: If your home predates 1978, do not scrape or disturb painted trim because doing so is a federal health hazard that requires a certified containment firm. You must also leave any second-story ladder measurements, structural header cuts, and safety glass replacement to a licensed contractor.
  • Climate-specific window replacement. Upstate metros like Troy experience brutal winter temperatures, which is why contractors focus on installing windows with the cold-climate energy rating (ENERGY STAR Northern V7.0, U-factor 0.22 or lower). Choosing the right rating prevents your home heating from escaping through the glass and lowers your heating bills during long winter stretches.
  • Lead-safe historic window replacement. Since more than half of New York's housing stock was built before 1978, professional focus is placed on replacing historic wood frames under federal safety guidelines (RRP). This specialized training ensures that old, lead laden paint layers are contained safely without contaminating your family's living areas.
  • Fiberglass frame upgrades for thermal stability. Our dramatic seasonal weather swings cause first-generation vinyl windows to warp, making fiberglass frames a highly popular local upgrade. These stable materials expand and contract at the same rate as the glass to protect the sealed glass unit (the two panes plus the spacer between them) from leaking.

Because New York has no statewide home-improvement license, you must vet installers based on local jurisdiction rules. Verify your contractor holds a New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection license if you live downstate, or a county-level registration on Long Island. For older homes in historic areas like Albany or Buffalo, ensure your window replacement company holds the federal lead-safe firm certification (RRP). They should also understand how to match the correct energy package to your specific region of our diverse state.

Best Pick Reports simplifies your search by verifying local contractors for you. Every certified company in their directory earns placement through a rigorous six-step merit-based review that cannot be purchased. Each team must maintain a 4.0 or higher Google rating or an 80 percent satisfaction rating on independent customer surveys. Furthermore, hiring a licensed window installer through this resource unlocks the $2,500 Best Pick Guarantee to protect your project.