Best Handyman Companies in Long Island
Long Island

Best Handyman Companies in Long Island

Find trusted handyman services professionals serving Long Island. All contractors are independently researched and certified.

Only companies with a Certified Best Pick® badge meet our strict satisfaction & licensing requirements and are eligible for the Best Pick Guarantee.

1
Recommended Pros
287+
Verified Reviews
Locally FocusedResearch-VerifiedFree Service

1 Contractors

Only companies with a Certified Best Pick® badge meet our strict satisfaction & licensing requirements and are eligible for the Best Pick Guarantee.

Mr. Handyman Serving Huntington, Smithtown, and Islip
Certified Best Pick

Mr. Handyman Serving Huntington, Smithtown, and Islip

Certified Pro

Discover the exceptional quality and reliability of Mr. Handyman, your locally owned and operated experts in home and business repairs and improvements. We're proud of our dedicated team, our reputation for excellence, and our commitment to top-notch service and craftsmanship, all backed by our one-year Done Right Promise.

2nd year as a Best Pick Insured Workers' Comp

Recent Project Requests in Long Island

Real homeowners looking for handyman services in your area

Centerport

"Want to turn a closet into open shelving with draws. Stain a wood wall Paint a stairwell Just pricing out estima..."

Feb 25, 2026
St James

"Exterior house wood rot repair. Wood porch and trim repair and replace. Thank you!"

Apr 15, 2025
Long Island

"I have 4 damaged ceramic floor tiles in my kitchen that I would like to replace. Is this too small of a job? I have the..."

Apr 8, 2025
melville

"screen door for front door came disattached from the house. needs to be securely reattached. hole(about a foot long..."

Sep 13, 2024
Certification Standards

How Long Island Handyman Companies Earn Best Pick Certification

Only handyman companies that meet our strict standards earn Best Pick status.

Customer Satisfaction

Handyman companies must maintain a 4.0+ rating and an 80% recommendation rate.

Licensing & Insurance

Current state contractor license verification and general liability insurance for handyman work

Business Stability

Minimum 1 year in business with established local presence

Verified State Standing

Maintain active business registration and in good standing with the state

Operational Excellence

Consistent handyman service quality across all projects

Annual Re-Certification

Must re-qualify every year through new research

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Certified Best Pick® handyman services companies in Long Island

Best Pick Certified Handyman Services companies in Long Island have earned their status through independent consumer research—not paid placement. To qualify, a company must meet strict standards:

  • High customer satisfaction: 4.0+ Google rating (25+ reviews) OR 80%+ recommendation rate from surveyed customers
  • Verified credentials: Active state licenses, general liability insurance, and workers' comp (where required)
  • Financial stability: Clean credit history and active Secretary of State standing
  • Local track record: Minimum 1 year serving the Long Island area

Certification is re-verified annually, ensuring continued performance.

No. Handyman Services companies cannot buy Best Pick Certification, improved ratings, or better placement. Our research team independently evaluates companies based on customer satisfaction, licensing, insurance, and business stability—before any business relationship exists.

Companies that earn certification pay a participation fee after qualifying, which covers the cost of ongoing research and publication. This fee has no influence on whether a company qualifies or how they appear in our directory.

The Best Pick Guarantee provides financial protection—up to $2,500 in labor costs—if a Certified Best Pick Handyman Services company fails to deliver on their commitments.

To be eligible:

  • Contact the company through Best Pick Reports or BestPickReports.com
  • Register for the guarantee (free)
  • Submit any claim within 45 days of the final date of service
  • Allow the company the opportunity to resolve the issue first

This guarantee applies only to Certified Best Pick companies, not Standard Pros. Full terms are available on our guarantee page.