When To Replace a Toilet

Do you ever really think about flushing your toilet? As important as your toilet is, most of us take it for granted that it will always work. However, every toilet will need to be replaced eventually. We explain the main reason you will need to replace a toilet. Plus, we outline the warning signs that it’s time to replace your toilet and provide some basic tips on how long each of the main components of your toilet will last.

When Should You Replace a Toilet?

There are several reasons you may need to replace a toilet:

1. Leaks – If you notice any water leaking from the base of the toilet, it’s likely time for a replacement. This could be caused by a faulty seal or a crack in the porcelain.
2. Constant clogging or plumbing issues: If you find yourself frequently dealing with clogged or backed-up toilets, it may be time to consider replacing the toilet.
3. Visible cracks or damage to the porcelain: Cracks or damage to the porcelain can weaken the structure of the toilet and make it more prone to problems. If you notice any visible damage, it may be time to replace the toilet.
4. High water bills: If you have noticed a sudden increase in your water bills, it may be due to an inefficient toilet. Replacing the toilet with a more efficient model can help lower your water usage and reduce your bills.
5. The toilet is old and outdated: If your toilet is old and outdated, it may not be as efficient as newer models. Replacing an old toilet with a newer, more efficient model can save water and money on your water bill.
6. Style or aesthetics: Alternatively, you may want to replace your toilet to change the style or look of your bathroom. Newer models offer features like a sleek design, soft-close seat, or even a bidet.
7. Accessibility and convenience: Lastly, you might need to replace it with a more convenient or accessible toilet. These include taller or high-profile options or additional safety options.

Warning Signs You May Need To Replace Your Toilet

It’s important to know when it’s time to replace your toilet. A faulty or outdated toilet can cause a variety of problems, from water damage to plumbing issues. Here are some warning signs that you may need to replace your toilet:

• Water or waste leaks on the floor around the toilet bowl
• Water leaks from the toilet tank
• It smells like sewage before or after flushing
• You have frequent clogs, backs-up, or overflows
• It does not flush properly or at all
• The porcelain is cracked, chipped, or damaged
• The water runs in between flushes

Depending on the cause of the issue, you will either need to make repairs, replace certain parts, or replace the toilet altogether.

If you need help determining the cause of the problem or when to replace your toilet, contact a local plumber for assistance.

How Long Does a Toilet Last?

Technically, a toilet will last more than 50 years, but that does not mean all the parts will last that long. You will need to replace certain parts more frequently. The porcelain tank and bowl are much more durable than the flushing mechanism and toilet seat.

• Porcelain toilet tank and bowl: 50 – 100 years
• Flushing assembly or mechanism: 8 – 12 years
• Toilet lid and seat: 4 – 12 years
• Water supply line: 20 – 30 years
• Wax ring: 30 – 50 years

Toilet Tank and Bowl

On average, a toilet can last for 50 to 100 years with proper maintenance. However, this can vary depending on the quality of the toilet, how often it is used, and how well it is maintained. Some higher quality toilets may last longer, while cheaper models or those that are not properly maintained may need to be replaced sooner.

Older toilets tend to be less efficient and can lead to higher water bills. Additionally, they will not have the same features and conveniences that modern toilets offer. Replacing an older toilet with a newer model can also help improve the overall look of your bathroom.

It’s a good idea to regularly inspect your toilet for any visible signs of wear and tear, such as cracks or leaks, and to address any issues as soon as they arise to extend the life of your toilet. Watch for leaks frequently and make repairs when necessary.

Flushing Assembly

The flushing mechanism or assembly includes the flush valve, fill valve, flapper, and several other parts that allow you to flush your toilet. While these are all parts you can replace separately, it’s usually recommended that you replace them all together to prevent leaks and keep your toilet working properly.

As such, the average lifespan of the flushing mechanism is between 8 and 12 years. The quality of the materials, the mineral content of your water, and how often you flush the toilet will determine exactly how long it will last. If you have hard water or use your toilet frequently, you may need to replace the assembly more often.

Toilet Lid and Seat

Toilet lids and seats will last 4 to 12 years depending on the material, how often you use the seat, and whether it is properly maintained. Plastic or PVC seats are the most reliable, whereas wood and padded vinyl seats can wear out more easily.

Soft-closing toilet seats might only last 6 to 8 years if they are frequently opened or used incorrectly. The hinges are filled with a fluid that causes the lid to close slowly. However, the hinge can get stuck or not work properly if the fluid leaks.

Water Supply Line

The water supply line delivers water to the toilet tank, keeping it filled and allowing you to flush the toilet. While rigid copper or chrome-plated brass lines are available, most supply lines are made of either flexible plastic or stain steel.

Rigid supply lines will last for decades, but they are easier to bend, crack, or damage. Flexible stainless stain supply lines will usually last 25 years or more, while plastic lines will last between 15 and 20.

Wax Ring

The wax ring attaches to the toilet flange and forms a seal between the toilet bowl and the waste pipe. It is an essential part of the toilet installation process and prevents leaks and odors from escaping. When properly installed, a wax ring will easily last 30 to 50 years or more. However, the wax will eventually dry out or wear way and allow odors or even waste to leak out.

Need professional help? Find a local Best Pick® plumber in your area now.